Strasburg v. Commission
About This Legal Opinion
The Tax Court reduced the value of a conservation easement on a 320 acre parcel on the upper Boulder River in Montana from 55% to 44% of the value of the property. This is the first case approving a deduction for an amendment to a conservation easement.
Membership Required
This resource is a Land Trust Alliance member benefit for the staff, board and volunteers of land trust and affiliate member organizations, and Alliance donors at the Protector level.
Lane County Assessor v Briggs
The board of property tax appeals reduced the real market value of property and the County seeks to have its value increased.
Mount Aldie, LLC v. Land Trust of Virginia, Inc. – Opinion on remand
In 2008, a landowner gifted a conservation easement over a 60-acre wooded parcel to the Land Trust of Virginia that established a 100-foot buffer area along the Little River. This case is an unfortunate example of the perils of conservation easement drafting.
Practice 11H – Conservation Easement Amendment Policy
This is a template for a conservation easement amendment policy that was reviewed and approved by the Land Trust Accreditation Commission.
Sample for Practice 11H: SPNHF Amendment Policy
This document from the accredited Society for the Protection of New Hampshire Forests details the Forest Society's Conservation Easement Amendment Policy and the specific conditions of the amendment policy as well as the procedures for requesting and approving an amendment.
Mount Aldie, LLC v. Land Trust of Virginia, Inc. (second appeal)
In 2008, a landowner gifted a conservation easement over a 60-acre wooded parcel to the Land Trust of Virginia that established a 100-foot buffer area along the Little River. This case is an unfortunate example of the perils of conservation easement drafting.
Wendell Falls Development, LLC v. Commissioner
The Tax Court denied the deduction because the LLC conveyed the easement with the expectation of receiving a substantial benefit of increased value to the residential lots in the PUD from being located near conserved land thereby outweighing any value of the easement. No penalties.
Strasburg v. Commissioner
This opinion confirms the conventional wisdom that an amendment that strengthens a conservation easement's restrictions can indeed qualify for a charitable deduction.
Memorandum on the Kiva Dunes Tax Court Case
This is a summary of a US Tax Court in which the IRS challenged a conservation easement on 141 acres of Alabama coastal land, part of which included a golf course. After trial and briefing, the IRS dropped its challenge of the easement’s conservation values and focused on valuation.
Upper Peninsula Land Conservancy v. Township of Michigamme
In 2014, Mark Murphy donated a 600-acre parcel to the accredited Upper Peninsula Land Conservancy. The property hosted habitat for a variety of animals, including moose, loons and bald eagles. The public was allowed to recreate on the property, but access was challenging.
Kiva Dunes Conservation, LLC, E.A., Drummond, Tax Matters - opinion
Tax Court opinion upholding the easement, the deduction for a stewardship endowment, and reducing the value of the donation.