Plateau Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner
Author
About This Legal Opinion
In December 2012, an investor acquired a 99% indirect ownership interest in 2,444 acres for $5.8 million. After donating conservation easements on all but 90 acres, a charitable deduction of $25.5 million was claimed based on before/after appraisals of $29.3 million and $3.8 million. IRS challenged.
Membership Required
This resource is a Land Trust Alliance member benefit for the staff, board and volunteers of land trust and affiliate member organizations, and Alliance donors at the Protector level.
Explore related resources
Black Farm Families Are Losing Their Land. New State Laws Seek to Help.
In 1910, rural African American farm families held between 16 million and 19 million acres of farmland, but the latest Census of Agriculture shows the amount of land held by African American farmers with active farms has dropped to just over 2.5 million acres.
TOT Property Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner
In 2005, George Dixson purchased 652 acres of undeveloped land for $486,000 that was later transferred into the TOT Property Holdings, LLC (LLC). In December 2013, an investor purchased 99% of LLC shares for $1,039,000, then claimed a charitable deduction of $6.9 million on a conservation easement.
Sells v. Commissioner
In 1999, Steven Moses bought 398 acres of land in Calhoun County for $2.4 million. He and others formed an LLC to buy the 236 acres and then donate a conservation easement on it to Chattowah Open Land Trust in Dec. 2003. The IRS challenged both the easement deduction and the timber value deduction.
Oakbrook Land Holdings LLC, v. Commissioner
Investors purchased 143 acres on White Oak Mountain near Chattanooga, Tennessee, for $1.7 million in December 2007. Oakbrook granted a conservation easement on 106 acres a year later and claimed a $9,545,000 value for the easement — a 700% appreciation in value.
Oakbrook Land Holdings LLC, v. Commissioner__full tax court
Investors purchased 143 acres on White Oak Mountain near Chattanooga, Tennessee, for $1.7 million in December 2007. Oakbrook granted a conservation easement on 106 acres a year later and claimed a $9,545,000 value for the easement — a 700% appreciation in value.
Oakbrook Land Holdings LLC, v. Commissioner__memo opinion
Investors purchased 143 acres on White Oak Mountain near Chattanooga, Tennessee, for $1.7 million in December 2007. Oakbrook granted a conservation easement on 106 acres a year later and claimed a $9,545,000 value for the easement — a 700% appreciation in value.
Railroad Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner
In 2012, Railroad Holdings LLC granted conservation easement on 452-acre parcel to the SE Regional Land Conservancy and claimed a $16 million charitable contribution deduction. The easement contained a termination proceeds provision that differed from the language of Reg. § 1.170A-14(g)(6)(ii).
North American Wetlands Conservation Act
NAWCA has helped to fund more than 3,200 projects protecting more than 31 million acres of wetland and wildlife habitat in all 50 states, as well as Canada and Mexico.
County of Humboldt v. McKee
The importance of this case in California cannot be understated, as over half of the state's 29 million acres of agricultural land was in Williamson Act contracts at the time of the case. A contrary result would have created chaos in administering the program.
Memorandum on the Kiva Dunes Tax Court Case
This is a summary of a US Tax Court in which the IRS challenged a conservation easement on 141 acres of Alabama coastal land, part of which included a golf course. After trial and briefing, the IRS dropped its challenge of the easement’s conservation values and focused on valuation.